How to Overcome the Challenges of a Nursing Home Abuse Lawsuit

How to Overcome the Challenges of a Nursing Home Abuse Lawsuit

Nursing Home Abuse Lawsuits

Filing a Nursing Home Abuse Lawsuit? Prepare for the Road Ahead & Learn How An Attorney Can Help You Succeed.

Available 24/7

Free Case Evaluation

Do you believe that you or a loved one has been abused by the staff in a nursing home facility? If so, you are not alone. Nursing home abuse, the mistreatment of nursing home residents by their caretakers, is a widespread problem in the US. The World Health Organization indicates that rates of elder abuse are concerningly high in elder care institutions. In fact, 2 in 3 nursing home staff members reported some form of abuse towards residents in a single year. Yet as few as 1 in 14 cases of elder abuse are reported.  

Although victims and their loved ones commonly feel guilt or shame in the wake of nursing home abuse, you are not at fault. These institutions have a legal and ethical responsibility to ensure safe, humane care for you or your loved one. When they fail to uphold that responsibility, they must be held accountable for violating your rights. Fortunately, there are steps you can take, protected under tort law, to prevent further injustices and seek remedies for yourself.  

This article will prepare you for the most common challenges faced when pursuing a nursing home abuse lawsuit; followed by success stories, and how an attorney will navigate you through the process of attaining justice and compensation.  

Get your Free Consultation From Our Personal Injury Law Firm Today!

Florida Nursing Home Abuse

Filing a Nursing Home Abuse Lawsuit

Victims of nursing home abuse often suffer from stress, frustration, and anxiety. Thus, following up with a lawsuit may feel like a daunting step to take. However, with the help of an attorney, victory is certainly attainable.  

 

In the state of Florida, you have two years from the date of the incident to claim compensation. To file a nursing home abuse lawsuit, you’ll need to establish, and have evidence that supports, the link between the damage you’ve experienced and the caretakers’ misconduct. For a detailed guide on types of nursing home abuse, signs, and legal protections, read Identifying & Combating Nursing Home Abuse. 

Common challenges

Common Challenges Faced When Filing a Nursing Home Abuse Lawsuit

Many complications can arise when filing a nursing home abuse lawsuit, but knowledge is power. The more you know about these challenges, the better prepared you will be to fight them with confidence. 

 

Delays

One of the more common frustrations faced when filing a nursing home abuse lawsuit is delays or lengthy legal processes. Reasons for delay often involve (1) strategically lengthy negotiations with the institution and insurance representatives; (2) waiting for a trial date if a settlement isn’t reached; (3) post-trial appeals. Depending on the unique circumstances surrounding your case, the entire process may take anywhere from a month or two to over a year. 

Delays may often result in stress for victims as they are already facing a wide range of challenges, e.g., financial restraints due to medical expenses. However, it is important to remember that they are a natural part of the process. Don’t let their representatives talk you into accepting a potentially bad deal with the promise of reaching a quicker resolution. When in doubt, rely on the counsel of your legal representative. 

 

Interference from Institutions and Insurers

In some nursing home abuse lawsuits, especially when larger entities are involved in the suit, the negotiation process can feel hostile. Often, the goal of both the institution and its insurers will be to minimize their financial liability. It is not uncommon to run into aggressive defense tactics. Fortunately, a lawyer is familiar with such tactics and has experience handling highly defensive parties. 

 

Determining Liability

Typically, nursing home facilities have multiple individual operators take on different responsibilities to create an overall care environment. Because of this, it may be difficult to discern which parties are liable. Liable entities may include staff, third-party contractors, upper management, and even larger corporate entities who own the facility. This is another situation where an experienced attorney’s eagle eye can help sort out what’s what. Your attorney will assess the evidence to determine any parties liable, even the less obvious ones. 

 

Gathering Supporting Evidence

Another common and stress-inducing obstacle faced in a nursing home abuse lawsuit is difficulty in acquiring evidence. Due to the ultra-involved nature of care institutions, crucial evidence can be a headache to obtain. 

 

Obtaining Records from the Facility

Medical records are often a key piece of evidence in injury cases. For nursing home abuse lawsuits, attaining such evidence may prove to be a difficult task since the at fault party, e.g., the facility, possess some, if not all, of this information. The facility may misplace or mishandle the information, or even purposely delay or withhold it. An easy resolution to this problem is to seek support from a nursing home abuse lawyer. An experienced attorney knows the processes and tactics to gather this type of evidence; this is especially helpful when the facility causes unnecessary difficulty. 

 

Obtaining Testimony from Residents

Witness testimony is another crucial piece of evidence needed to support nursing home abuse cases. Not only is attaining witness testimony challenging due to witness reluctance, but the opposing party may question the reliability of the testimony. It is important to hire a nursing home abuse attorney from the onset to collect and protect the testimony needed. 

 

Reluctance from Witnesses

Unfortunately, many residents who witness nursing home abuse are unlikely to report it due to fear of retaliation. Other factors which may affect willingness to report abuse may include: 

  • Downplaying the severity of the event 
  • Difficulty recalling precise details 
  • Feelings of shame and embarrassment.  

 

Testimony Called into Question

If a witness has problems with cognition, memory, or even communication, their ability to serve as a reliable witness may be called into question by the opposing party. Since cognitive disability and mental illness are noted risk factors for elder abuse, it’s important to seek out witnesses without cognitive impairments such as other healthcare staff not responsible for the abuse.  

Fighting for the Outcome You Deserve in a Nursing Home Abuse Lawsuit

 

In any nursing home abuse lawsuit, there will be obstacles to overcome. Yet the benefits of pursuing a suit can make it well worth any concerns you may have. A successful suit can not only bring a sense of relief but also bring about material changes for the better. You may receive compensatory damages to alleviate any financial burdens incurred. Additionally, in some cases, preventative action may be taken to reduce the likelihood of future incidents. The potential benefits of a nursing home abuse lawsuit can be observed through the outcomes of real cases. 

$2.34 Million in 2020 Nursing Home Negligence Case

In 2020, Betsy Jentz of Los Angeles, CA was admitted to Country Villa Wilshire Healthcare Center after hip surgery. While at this center, 84-year-old Jentz was subject to prolonged negligence because of the insufficient number of staff in the facility. Moreover, Jentz’s call light was out of reach and her room’s phone unplugged. These circumstances caused serious delays in staff response when Jentz needed assistance. The negligence led to at least ten falls, a fractured pelvis, and permanent damage to Jentz’s shoulder. The jury found that Jentz’s rights were violated 132 times while in the facility. Jentz’s case was awarded a total verdict of $2.34 million. 

$26 Million in 2023 Wrongful Death Case

Stephen Tate of Trumbull County, OH was shot in the head at the age of 19. He was left permanently disabled and in need of 24/7 supervising care, especially when eating. The facility in charge of Tate’s care, Signature HealthCARE of Warren, was reportedly both understaffed and mismanaged. In 2019, 69-year-old Tate was abandoned by staff to eat by himself and aspirated during his lunch. It took staff over 40 minutes to call an ambulance despite his condition. Tragically, Tate passed away on account of the damage. The lawyers representing Tate’s estate were able to secure a record-breaking $26 million verdict. The results included a wrongful death verdict, compensation for rights violations, and punitive damages. 

$1.2 Million in 2017 Physical Abuse Case

Eryetha Mayberry was a woman in her 90s suffering arthritis and dementia. In 2012, she was in the care of Quail Creek Nursing and Rehabilitation Center in Oklahoma City, OK. Mayberry’s family discovered certain items missing, as well as bruises on Mayberry’s arms and hands. Unable to get an explanation from the facility, the family placed a hidden camera in Mayberry’s room. On April 16th, 2012, the camera recorded footage of a nursing assistant physically abusing Mayberry. The employee slapped Mayberry in the face with latex gloves and then stuffed them in her mouth, while another employee looked on. Mayberry’s family filed a suit after her death to seek compensation for her abuse. The suit led to a $1.2 million verdict in favor of Mayberry’s family. Reportedly, the care center has since undergone changes in management and implemented a more intensive employee screening process. 

How a Nursing Home Abuse Lawyer Can Help 

 

When considering a lawsuit for nursing home abuse, it can be hard to know what to expect. With all the complications that can arise, the anxiety can be overpowering. But you don’t have to handle any of these roadblocks alone. By seeking out an experienced nursing home abuse attorney, you can strengthen your case and lighten your load. Their skills and expertise can lower these hurdles and clear your path to financial compensation and peace of mind. 

 

Reducing Potential Complications 

Through experience and professional connections, they effectively navigate any complications while acquiring key evidence and testimony. Legal experts also understand liability intimately and can ensure you file your suit properly. Lastly, a lawyer has familiarity with the defensive tactics commonly employed by insurance companies. 

personal injury lawyer Scott Senft and Alex Senft back to back with crossed arms

Take The First Steps

At The Law Offices of Scott Jay Senft, we are committed to supporting you through the challenges of any litigation process. We have over 30 years of experience and the results to back it up. If you’re looking for skilled, reliable legal representative for a nursing home abuse lawsuit in the state of Florida, we may be able to help. If you suspect nursing home abuse, do not hesitate to contact us for a free consultation today with a nursing home abuse attorney. 

Identifying & Combating Nursing Home Abuse

Identifying & Combating Nursing Home Abuse

Identifying & Combating Nursing Home Abuse

Protect Your Loved Ones from Nursing Home Abuse. Learn About Legal Recourse, Rights Violations & Seeking Compensation. Call For Legal Counsel.

Comprehensive Legal Insights

Empower Yourself with Knowledge

Explore our in-depth resources to better understand your legal options and protections under Florida law.

Introduction

Understanding Nursing Home Abuse

Nursing home abuse is the mistreatment of older adults, by healthcare staff, in an assisted living facility. This mistreatment typically results in vulnerable adults experiencing physical harm, emotional trauma, and a diminished quality of life. Given the trust placed on healthcare professionals caring for our elders, discovering abuse or neglect can be deeply jarring. Unfortunately, 64.2% of staff in long term care facilities reported perpetrating some form of abuse. If you or a loved one has experienced any form of nursing home abuse, it is crucial that you seek the services of a skilled attorney. A nursing home abuse attorney will navigate the legal process of pursuing compensation and ensure that justice is served. By holding the responsible parties accountable, you will receive the remedies needed to combat the abuse and move toward recovery, while also preventing the abuse of others. 

Legal Protections for Nursing Home Abuse

Florida Statute 400.022 mandates that nursing home facilities must adopt, publicize, and adhere to a comprehensive set of residents’ rights. These rights ensure that nursing home staff respect the civil, religious, and personal liberties of residents. Key protections include the right to private communication, visitation, and the ability to present grievances without fear of retaliation.

 

Residents are also entitled to:

 

    • Manage their own finances. 
    • Receive adequate health care. 
    • Participate in medical decision-making. 
    • Live free from mental and physical abuse, including improper use of restraints. 
    • Be fully informed about their medical condition, treatment options, and any changes to their care. 
    • Maintain privacy and dignity in all personal and medical matters. 

Legally Required Disclosure of the Law

To ensure compliance with these protections, nursing home licensees must inform residents and staff of their rights, provide comprehensive staff training, and conduct regular inspections. Staff must clearly communicate these rights to residents both orally and in writing at the time of admission and throughout their stay. This transparency ensures that residents are fully aware of their entitlements and protections, empowering them to advocate for themselves and seek help if their rights are violated. Unfortunately, these rights are not always disclosed to residents, leading to tragic outcomes. Therefore, it is crucial to be vigilant for signs of nursing home abuse to protect your loved ones. 

Signs of Abuse to Look Out For 

Identifying the signs of abuse in a nursing home is crucial for ensuring that our loved ones are properly cared for. Abuse can be subtle or overt but recognizing the warning signs can prevent severe injury and provide an opportunity for intervention. Below are some common signs of nursing home abuse to be vigilant about: 

Unexplained Injuries

Look for bruises, cuts, burns, or fractures that cannot be explained by the staff. These may be signs of physical abuse or neglect. 

Changes in Behavior

Notice any sudden or unusual changes in behavior, such as withdrawal, fearfulness, or aggression. These changes can indicate psychological abuse or emotional distress. 

Poor Hygiene

Pay attention to the cleanliness of the residents and their living environment. Poor personal hygiene, dirty bedding, and unsanitary conditions can be signs of neglect or substandard care. 

Weight Loss or Dehydration

Significant or unexplained weight loss and signs of dehydration may indicate neglect, such as failing to provide adequate nutrition and hydration. 

Bedsores

The presence of bedsores, particularly severe ones, often points to neglect and a lack of proper medical care. 

Medication Errors

Look out for signs that medication is not being administered correctly, such as frequent illnesses, unusual side effects, or a decline in health. 

Taking Legal Action Against Your Nursing Home 

 

Florida Statute 400.102 provides the legal framework for holding nursing homes accountable for misconduct and negligence. This statute allows legal action to be taken if there are intentional or negligent acts that significantly impact the health or safety of residents. Key areas covered by this statute include: 

Misappropriation/

Conversion of Property

 

Unauthorized use or theft of a resident’s property. 

Non-compliance: Mental Health Procedures

 

Failing to follow proper procedures for transporting, admitting, or examining residents under mental health laws. 

Fraudulent Records

 

 

Altering or falsifying medical or nursing home records. 

Abuse Explained

Types of Abuse in Nursing Homes

Nursing home abuse can manifest in various forms, each causing significant harm to vulnerable residents. Understanding the different types of elder abuse is crucial for identifying and preventing these heinous acts. Below are the various forms of abuse residents can encounter in assisted care facilities. 

Physical Abuse

Physical abuse in nursing homes involves the use of physical force against elderly residents, resulting in bodily harm, impairment, or pain. This form of abuse can have severe physical and emotional consequences, compromising the safety and dignity of the elderly. Examples of physical abuse include: 

  • Striking or Hitting: Using hands or objects to hit residents, causing bruises, cuts, or fractures. 
  • Force-Feeding: Forcing residents to eat or drink against their will, which can lead to choking, aspiration, or other medical complications. 
  • Improper Medication Use: Administering medications inappropriately, such as overmedicating to sedate a resident or withholding necessary medications, leading to adverse health effects. 
  • Physical Restraints: Using restraints, such as straps or belts, to immobilize residents without medical justification, which can result in injuries and loss of mobility. 
  • Pushing or Shoving: Using unnecessary force to move residents, causing falls or other injuries. 
  • Rough Handling: Handling residents roughly during transfers, bathing, or other activities, leading to pain and discomfort. 

Physical abuse not only causes immediate physical injuries but can also lead to long-term psychological trauma. It is essential for families to recognize the signs of physical abuse, such as unexplained bruises, fractures, or a sudden change in the resident’s behavior. 

Sexual Abuse

Sexual abuse in nursing homes involves any non-consensual sexual contact or intercourse with elderly residents. This form of abuse is a grave violation of the resident’s dignity and personal integrity, often leading to severe emotional and psychological trauma. Examples of sexual abuse include: 

  • Unwanted Touching: Any form of non-consensual physical contact, such as groping or fondling. 
  • Sexual Assault: Forced or coerced sexual acts, including intercourse, that the resident did not consent to. 
  • Coerced Nudity: Forcing residents to undress or exposing them against their will. 
  • Photographing Residents Naked: Taking inappropriate photos of residents without their consent, violating their privacy and dignity. 
  • Sexual Harassment: Making sexual comments, gestures, or advances that make the resident feel uncomfortable or threatened. 
  • Exposing Residents to Pornographic Material: Subjecting residents to pornographic content without their consent. 

Sexual abuse can lead to a range of negative outcomes, including anxiety, depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). It is crucial for families and caregivers to be vigilant for signs of sexual abuse, such as unexplained injuries to private areas, sudden changes in behavior, or expressions of fear around certain staff members. If you suspect sexual abuse, it is vital to seek legal assistance immediately to ensure the resident’s safety and hold the perpetrators accountable. 

Psychological Abuse

Psychological abuse, also known as emotional abuse, is a harmful behavior in nursing homes that can lead to psychological trauma, including anxiety, chronic depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). This form of abuse often involves a power imbalance, with caregivers exerting control over vulnerable residents. 

In nursing homes, psychological abuse can manifest through: 

  • Verbal Assaults: Insulting or ridiculing residents, damaging their self-esteem and dignity. 
  • Harassment: Continuous distressing behavior causing significant stress and anxiety. 
  • Humiliation: Embarrassing or shaming residents, making them feel inferior. 
  • Intimidation: Using threats to instill fear and control residents. 
  • Isolation: Deliberately keeping residents away from family and friends, leading to loneliness and helplessness. 
  • Gaslighting: Manipulating residents into doubting their own memories or perceptions, causing confusion. 
  • Ignoring Conflicts: Failing to address conflicts between residents, creating a hostile environment and emotional distress. 

Neglecting the emotional needs of residents or treating them like children can also be forms of psychological abuse. These actions not only affect mental well-being but can also lead to physical health problems due to stress and anxiety. 

Financial Exploitation

Financial exploitation is a form of abuse in nursing homes where caregivers or others in a position of trust manipulate or steal the financial resources of elderly residents. This exploitation can severely impact the financial stability and overall well-being of the elderly, often leaving them without the means to support themselves. Examples of financial exploitation include: 

  • Theft of Assets: Stealing money, jewelry, or other valuable possessions from residents. 
  • Unauthorized Use of Funds: Using a resident’s bank account, credit cards, or other financial resources without permission for personal gain. 
  • Fraudulent Charges: Billing residents or their families for services that were not provided or were unnecessary. 
  • Identity Theft: Using the resident’s personal information to open credit accounts, apply for loans, or engage in other fraudulent activities. 
  • Coercion to Change Legal Documents: Forcing or manipulating residents to alter their wills, trusts, or powers of attorney to benefit the abuser. 
  • Deceptive Investment Schemes: Convincing residents to invest in fraudulent or risky ventures that deplete their savings. 

 Recognizing the signs of financial exploitation is crucial for protecting the elderly. Warning signs include unexplained withdrawals from bank accounts, missing personal items, sudden changes in financial habits, and the appearance of new, unexplained debt. 

Substandard Care

Substandard care involves providing care that falls below acceptable standards, leading to health deterioration, injuries, or other adverse outcomes for residents. This type of abuse can stem from a consistent pattern of inadequate care, significantly jeopardizing the well-being of nursing home residents. When substandard care results in physical or psychological harm, residents may be entitled to compensation. 

  

Examples of substandard care in nursing homes include: 

  

  • Poor Planning During Relocation: Inefficient or careless planning when moving residents between floors or rooms can cause confusion, distress, and physical harm. Proper coordination and communication are essential to ensure the safety and comfort of residents during relocations. 
  • Failing to Respond to Requests for Assistance: Ignoring or delaying responses to residents’ requests for help can lead to unsafe conditions. This negligence compromises the resident’s well-being and can result in serious health issues or injuries. 

Neglect

Neglect is the failure to provide necessities like food, hygiene, medical care, and safe living conditions. This form of abuse can severely impact the health and well-being of nursing home residents, leading to malnutrition, dehydration, infections, and untreated medical conditions.  

  

Examples of neglect in nursing homes include: 

 

  • Unsanitary Conditions: Leaving residents in dirty or unsafe environments, which can lead to infections and other health problems. 
  • Improper Medication Administration: Mistakes in medication administration, whether accidental or deliberate, can cause serious health issues and may constitute abuse. 
  • Ignoring Health Issues: Failing to address or properly treat health problems, leading to deterioration in the resident’s condition. 
  • Elderly Abandonment: Abandoning an elderly person, such as leaving them at a public place or hospital without arranging proper care, puts them at significant risk and causes distress. 

Steps to Take After Identifying Nursing Home Abuse

If residents or their families face any type of nursing home abuse, they should take the following steps to move forward: 

1

Document the Incidents

Keep detailed records of any instances of abuse, neglect, or rights violations, including dates, times, and descriptions of what occurred. 

2

Report to the Facility

Bring the issue to the nursing home administration’s attention to seek an immediate resolution. 

3

Contact a State Agency

Report the violation to the state agency responsible for overseeing nursing homes, such as the Department of Health or a similar entity. 

4

Seek Legal Advice

Consult with a personal injury attorney who specializes in nursing home abuse to explore legal options for compensation and to ensure the rights of the resident are protected.

Time Limits

What is the Statute of Limitations for Nursing Home Abuse Cases?

The statute of limitations for nursing home abuse cases give you two years to file a claim from the moment the abuse is discovered. If you suspect or discover that a loved one has been abused in a nursing home, it’s essential to act quickly and consult with a nursing home abuse attorney. Prompt legal action can help secure the necessary evidence and build a strong case to seek justice and compensation for the abuse suffered. Moreover, the personal injury attorneys at The Law Offices of Scott Senft work on a contingency plan, meaning you don’t pay an upfront fee. If we attain a settlement on your behalf, our small, pre-approved percentage is deducted to pay for our services.  

Florida auto accident law team

Get Your Free Consultation Today

With over thirty years of experience in personal injury, Scott Senft and his team possesses the knowledge to handle complex types of nursing home abuse. If you have any questions regarding abuse in a nursing home or health care facility, don’t hesitate to call our offices for more information. An attorney is available at any time for a free consultation.  After identifying nursing home abuse, it is important to act fact as personal injury claims fall under a statute of limitations.  

954-505-2183